I occasionally get the chance to put down a song, and if I get that far, then it can be quite helpful to get some feedback on it. I have entered a few of my songs into the Song of The Year competition, and also taken advantage of their “critique” service where they rank the song in 10 categories (e.g. emotional impact, technical eval, marketability etc). Now, I did once get Runner up for Oct 2006, which was quite exciting, but I was rather pleased to get back a critique on 2 of my recent song entries. The first, “Pear Shaped”, I got 10/10 in one category and 9/10 in 2 categories, better than ever I have got before. I have not finished this song, though, so have not uploaded it. The other song, Beat the Blues, I only entered by chance, and it got 10/10 for 3 of categories, and 9/10 for another 3. I especially liked the closing comment “This is well conceived and composed. The ideas are presented in a clear and professional manner. There is nothing to change. Exceptionally worthy work! This is an exceptional song and performance with formidable potential.” I thank the reviewer (whoever you are) wholeheartedly for that comment, as it really made me smile and feel good. All I need now is a great cover – now wouldn’t that be nice !
Yes, I had to pay for the review, so you need to discount something there, but it is nice to get praise some times ! I have found Song of the Year to be very good at customer service and response, and they get top marks for that. The critique service also represents good value, even though I am still not quite certain what it really tells me – but it does have motivational value, which is perhaps the main thing.
On the song competition front, it is always hard to tell what the value of a competition is. I always tended to assume that songs that won competitions would end up making it really big – but it doesn’t really seem to be the case. I also note that although Song of The Year lists many very famous songwriters/artists/music industry people as judges, I am pretty certain the majority of them only get involved in judging the years winning song from a shortlist – so don’t expect to enter and have your song heard by Norah Jones (one of the listed judges)! If you get to be a monthly winner, then you might do, but I think they get a lot of entries.
I don’t know if I am the only one, but I have great difficult in figuring out which category into which to enter a song. Is it pop, is it rock, country, blues or whatever? Maybe I have no sense of style, but maybe it is made hard so as to encourage entries (and payments) in multiple categories.
Another thing I would like would be to see the release form you have to sign to get the song sent out to industry contacts (assuming your song is a winner, of course) . I always feel a little nervous only seeing that kind of thing only after the event (assuming I should ever be that lucky). Surely there is nothing to hide…..
Well, it would be nice to be a winner one day, and, even better, to have a song covered and properly produced. Every song I do I think I get a little better (maybe 2 steps forward, one back), so maybe one day I will get there….
Epilog: None of the songs were in the top 5, but I again got a credit as Suggested Artist runner up.